Is the Disney Magic underwhelming compared to the Disney Wish?

My family went for our first cruise last Christmas aboard the Disney Wish and had the most amazing time. We loved meeting characters, chilling in the splash pad, and of course eating the food. We are itching to try another cruise and a Halloween on the High Seas cruise caught our eye. It is on the Disney Magic and I understand that it is a more intimate, older ship.

We watched some vlogs from folks who have stayed on the ship and we were underwhelmed by the theming compared to what we experienced on the Wish. Particularly in the rooms, where we do spend a decent amount of our time. I am wondering if people have experienced going from a new ship like the Wish to an older ship like the Magic, and what their experience was.

For our family, we really put a premium on character interactions and overall Disney vibes. We have two young children, so nightlife and thrills are not high on our list. Would love to get some input!