Disturbing games like Puppet combo (Night watch)

Sadly I have this thing where scary stuff isn't scary to me. I've played lots of horror games, for an example Silent Hill 2 Remake, it was even scary for me, nothing uneasy, no disturbance. I didn't feel a single emotion But are there any horror game like Puppet combo Night watch? The ending was truly disturbing for me, but I didn't feel fear again. But I felt very disturbed. Any games like that? It can be retro too, doesnt matter, good, bad graphics